Email: Password: Remember Me | Create Account (Free)

Back to Subject List

Old thread has been locked -- no new posts accepted in this thread
Per Westermark
07/09/09 13:46
Read: 201 times
Sweden


 
#166954 - Please tell again exactly what you expect your robot to do
Responding to: Andy Neil's previous message
A big problem here is - as already mentioned earlier - the accuracy of the GPS. It is good for navigation, telling where you are in a city or in a country. But it isn't good for controlling things, since roads are seldom wide enough to let you use the GPS to keep a vehicle on the road. And even if you have a very large grass area, much fun will be lost because of this accuracy issue.

When running a robot in a limited area, it is normally easier to draw cables on the floor or in the ground that will send a signal the robot can hear. Then you can frame the allowed area. Or you may use ultra-sound speakers/microphones to detect the location. Indoors, you could use optical detection, in case you have a patterned floor. As long as you have good enough contrast and large enough markers, you can use cameras outdoors too, scanning a 3D area.

So in the end - exactly how do you expect to use this GPS? You could calculate speed from the wheels, unless you have problems with wheel slip. You could calculate speed from photographing the ground. You are already planning to use a compass, in which case you don't need a GPS for direction. A GPS is way lousier at measuring height than it is at predicting your location.

The only time a GPS is really good enough for positioning a robot or vehicle is if you are navigating on the water not too close to the coast or if you have a DGPS that is computing a differential location based on a land-based radio reference. But a DGPS is quite expensive.

List of 24 messages in thread
TopicAuthorDate
interfacing GPS 15L with 8051 microcontroller      Rahul Batra      06/28/09 12:33      
   Time to start working      Per Westermark      06/28/09 13:18      
   Oh the poor boy is waiting      Jez Smith      06/28/09 13:25      
   How to proceed      Andy Neil      06/28/09 18:50      
   more info's      JecksonS Ben      06/29/09 03:47      
      USB host/device        Per Westermark      06/29/09 05:41      
         You don't mind if I tear my hair out for a bit do you      Jez Smith      06/29/09 07:41      
            I thought you *shave* your legs, Jez... ;-)      Jan Waclawek      06/29/09 07:49      
               Not shave...      Jez Smith      06/29/09 12:32      
                  No problem helping people - just not turn-key solutions      Per Westermark      06/29/09 13:16      
            He seems to have given up and gone away anyhow!      Andy Neil      06/29/09 07:56      
   i havent run away      Rahul Batra      07/08/09 04:13      
      System Design      Andy Neil      07/08/09 07:25      
         thats not all      Rahul Batra      07/09/09 12:46      
            take up the data from the GPS and run      Andy Neil      07/09/09 13:33      
               Please tell again exactly what you expect your robot to do      Per Westermark      07/09/09 13:46      
               its just about the confusion      Rahul Batra      07/19/09 06:19      
                  Dangerous      Per Westermark      07/19/09 07:03      
                     this doesnt sound good      Rahul Batra      07/20/09 06:56      
                        I might have misunderstod      Per Westermark      07/20/09 07:10      
                           what should be done than??      Rahul Batra      07/23/09 06:58      
                              impossible      Erik Malund      07/23/09 07:02      
                              On or the other - not both      Andy Neil      07/23/09 07:55      
   Some handy Software for GPS data...      Andy Neil      07/08/09 10:44      

Back to Subject List