Email: Password: Remember Me | Create Account (Free)

Back to Subject List

Old thread has been locked -- no new posts accepted in this thread
Justin Fontes
01/10/10 00:41
Read: 229 times
Woodland
USA


 
Msg Score: 0
 -1 Message Not Useful
 +1 Good Question
#172304 - Very tired of the "depends" response
Responding to: Kiran V. Sutar's previous message
In many replies, not just this thread, a lot of replies argue that the correct solution "depends on the application". I am now arguing that there are a finite number of communication portals to use and as such they are pre-defined and may or may not match an application. Instead of always relaying the same boring answer with no informative response maybe a more helpful approach would be to write a FAQ or create a tutorial on all the communication portals that could be potentially used. Implementing a parametric table would be greatly helpful to seasoned veterans who continously need communications which describe which portals would allow master-slave.... master-multi-slave.... master-master-slave... etc etc... and possibly implementing common properties as speed. If this has been done successfully on the internet, then obviously that link should be posted so that the OP knows the method to use with their application. The application chooses the communication portal, but the communication portal has already been defined. Of course, there might be the chance that none of the communication portals match the application, then what do you do?

List of 44 messages in thread
TopicAuthorDate
Connecting two 8051s      Poonam Kothawade      01/08/10 01:31      
   ther are lots of interfaces      Neil Kurzman      01/08/10 01:58      
      "RS232" (sic?)      Andy Neil      01/08/10 02:25      
         That is why i said type      Neil Kurzman      01/08/10 18:08      
      a slight difference of opinion      Erik Malund      01/08/10 07:43      
         I'm (probably) with Neil      Andy Neil      01/08/10 08:35      
            I do not, specifically if ...      Erik Malund      01/08/10 08:50      
               I thought you'd like that!      Andy Neil      01/08/10 09:33      
            I was looking from a code point of veiw      Neil Kurzman      01/08/10 18:14      
               if one was the best there would only be one.      Andy Neil      01/09/10 03:38      
               yes and no      Erik Malund      01/09/10 07:41      
      Lots of interfaces - Microwire; SPI; I2C      Andy Neil      01/08/10 08:31      
      parallel?      Maarten Brock      01/10/10 04:01      
   You may use whatever you like!      Andy Neil      01/08/10 02:18      
   I2C is serial communication.      Richard Erlacher      01/08/10 09:44      
      Already noted      Andy Neil      01/08/10 10:50      
         Sorry ... didn't mean to steal your thunder ...      Richard Erlacher      01/08/10 12:49      
   Is this (question) a Joke ...???      Kiran V. Sutar      01/09/10 12:25      
      Very tired of the "depends" response      Justin Fontes      01/10/10 00:41      
         Agreed...but this happens always...      Kiran V. Sutar      01/10/10 01:21      
         I think you missed the point!        Andy Neil      01/10/10 02:41      
            Re: 'Depends'..      Gopal Amlekar      01/10/10 06:53      
               it's typical ...      Richard Erlacher      01/10/10 08:18      
               All too common!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 08:52      
            FAQ isn't easy - flowchart not adequate      Per Westermark      01/10/10 07:12      
               Exactly!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 08:50      
            You wouldn't do it in everyday life - so why do it here?!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 09:00      
         Concrete enough?        Kai Klaas      01/10/10 13:31      
            Wow!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 16:28      
               Yes, for a while...      Kai Klaas      01/11/10 08:42      
         Well.. is this pretty good?        Justin Fontes      01/11/10 21:15      
            Still missing the point?      Andy Neil      01/12/10 03:41      
               Youre missing my point      Justin Fontes      01/12/10 10:48      
                  Exactly!!      Kai Klaas      01/12/10 11:12      
                  I see - but disagree      Andy Neil      01/12/10 11:21      
                  not 'demanding' but 'asking' is encouraged      Erik Malund      01/12/10 11:35      
                     Still often not possible to help...        Per Westermark      01/12/10 17:45      
                  I agree Justin..but...      Kiran V. Sutar      01/13/10 04:09      
                     Lots of usage details possible without giving product away      Per Westermark      01/13/10 08:29      
                     My answer was to be quiet!      Kai Klaas      01/13/10 08:35      
                  I will admit....      Justin Fontes      01/13/10 11:38      
                     That's why folks should search before posting!      Richard Erlacher      01/13/10 12:21      
   Please provide more details...      Anurag Mishra      03/22/10 07:06      
      Don't you think it's a bit late for that?!      Andy Neil      03/22/10 07:16      

Back to Subject List