Email: Password: Remember Me | Create Account (Free)

Back to Subject List

Old thread has been locked -- no new posts accepted in this thread
Kiran V. Sutar
01/13/10 04:09
Modified:
  01/13/10 04:12

Read: 234 times
Mumbai
India


 
#172419 - I agree Justin..but...
Responding to: Justin Fontes's previous message
Hi Justin Fontes,

Just review this thread from the first post:

Look at the first post in this thread by the OP.
Poonam Kothawade said:

I want to connect two 8051 .
Shall I use I2C or serial communication?


What would be your answer?
Look at the number of posts in this thread talking about I2C and UART.

After all those many posts...if the OP now tells you that:
1. the 2 8051s are on the same board...what will be your answer? or
2. the distance between 8051s is 10mtrs or more, with noisy environment...what will be your answer? or
3. the speed of data transfer is >1Mhz...what will be your answer? or
4.....

How would you feel after about 30~40 posts in this thread the OP gives the above information.
Let us assume "the OP says it is Option 1 above."
Now how would the other members feel when they have posted for serial communication, SPI, Parallel... Wouldn't they feel, that their precious time would have been saved, if the OP had given this information in the first post?

There are "n" number of possible answers to the OPs question.
You cannot suggest the right solution unless you know some more details about the product.
Justin Fontes said:

There is no need in telling everybody every detail about the project which basically opens the portal to stealing of ideas.

(Well, I am NOT asking to divert the core design of the product), but you can atleast give this much information?
We never asked "what is your product", or "other product details", we have asked only the information related to the question; so that the OP gets to the solution fast. And, I don't think, anybody can copy the product just by answering the above questions !!!
OP asked only for "how to connect" she never diverted the information of what data is flowing between the 8051s, or what is the product?

In so many years, I do not remember a single incident when anybody has asked for product details other than that required to come to a solution for the OPs question.

Edit:
My argument is the OP must give some background information about the question, that will help to come to solution very quickly. It will save everybody's time and energy.


List of 44 messages in thread
TopicAuthorDate
Connecting two 8051s      Poonam Kothawade      01/08/10 01:31      
   ther are lots of interfaces      Neil Kurzman      01/08/10 01:58      
      "RS232" (sic?)      Andy Neil      01/08/10 02:25      
         That is why i said type      Neil Kurzman      01/08/10 18:08      
      a slight difference of opinion      Erik Malund      01/08/10 07:43      
         I'm (probably) with Neil      Andy Neil      01/08/10 08:35      
            I do not, specifically if ...      Erik Malund      01/08/10 08:50      
               I thought you'd like that!      Andy Neil      01/08/10 09:33      
            I was looking from a code point of veiw      Neil Kurzman      01/08/10 18:14      
               if one was the best there would only be one.      Andy Neil      01/09/10 03:38      
               yes and no      Erik Malund      01/09/10 07:41      
      Lots of interfaces - Microwire; SPI; I2C      Andy Neil      01/08/10 08:31      
      parallel?      Maarten Brock      01/10/10 04:01      
   You may use whatever you like!      Andy Neil      01/08/10 02:18      
   I2C is serial communication.      Richard Erlacher      01/08/10 09:44      
      Already noted      Andy Neil      01/08/10 10:50      
         Sorry ... didn't mean to steal your thunder ...      Richard Erlacher      01/08/10 12:49      
   Is this (question) a Joke ...???      Kiran V. Sutar      01/09/10 12:25      
      Very tired of the "depends" response      Justin Fontes      01/10/10 00:41      
         Agreed...but this happens always...      Kiran V. Sutar      01/10/10 01:21      
         I think you missed the point!        Andy Neil      01/10/10 02:41      
            Re: 'Depends'..      Gopal Amlekar      01/10/10 06:53      
               it's typical ...      Richard Erlacher      01/10/10 08:18      
               All too common!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 08:52      
            FAQ isn't easy - flowchart not adequate      Per Westermark      01/10/10 07:12      
               Exactly!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 08:50      
            You wouldn't do it in everyday life - so why do it here?!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 09:00      
         Concrete enough?        Kai Klaas      01/10/10 13:31      
            Wow!      Andy Neil      01/10/10 16:28      
               Yes, for a while...      Kai Klaas      01/11/10 08:42      
         Well.. is this pretty good?        Justin Fontes      01/11/10 21:15      
            Still missing the point?      Andy Neil      01/12/10 03:41      
               Youre missing my point      Justin Fontes      01/12/10 10:48      
                  Exactly!!      Kai Klaas      01/12/10 11:12      
                  I see - but disagree      Andy Neil      01/12/10 11:21      
                  not 'demanding' but 'asking' is encouraged      Erik Malund      01/12/10 11:35      
                     Still often not possible to help...        Per Westermark      01/12/10 17:45      
                  I agree Justin..but...      Kiran V. Sutar      01/13/10 04:09      
                     Lots of usage details possible without giving product away      Per Westermark      01/13/10 08:29      
                     My answer was to be quiet!      Kai Klaas      01/13/10 08:35      
                  I will admit....      Justin Fontes      01/13/10 11:38      
                     That's why folks should search before posting!      Richard Erlacher      01/13/10 12:21      
   Please provide more details...      Anurag Mishra      03/22/10 07:06      
      Don't you think it's a bit late for that?!      Andy Neil      03/22/10 07:16      

Back to Subject List