Email: Password: Remember Me | Create Account (Free)

Back to Subject List

Old thread has been locked -- no new posts accepted in this thread
Andy Neil
03/18/12 01:45
Read: 462 times
Basingstoke
Uk


 
#186763 - Specification Inadequate - Language Barrier?
Responding to: Erik Malund's previous message
Erik Malund said:
Objects are inserted manually, one at the time by free fall through tube by gravity.
Tube is a part of some kind of garbage collecting machine so objects can be made of all kinds of material and their mixtures.

what about a hinged spring loaded lid (such a lid opens when an object is placed on it) and connecting a detector (e.g. hall-effect) to it.

So long as it's guaranteed that they are only ever inserted one at a time (as stated), then having a door and counting each time the door is opened sounds ideal!

However, when you say "manually" that means that it's a person inserting the objects - doesn't it?
How do you ensure that the person never inserts 2 or more objects at once?

Tube can hold just one object at the time.
I guess there is a language problem here.

I think you're right!

It sounds like the OP meant objects passing through a tube?

Again, this leads to the question, "what is the purpose of counting the objects?"
If the requirement is to determine when the receptacle at the end of the tube is full, then simply counting the objects is of very little use!

http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs....html#goal

The OP needs to give a full & complete definition of the requirement.

List of 23 messages in thread
TopicAuthorDate
counting objects inserted in tube      Damir Tadic      03/17/12 02:28      
   Cheaper?      Per Westermark      03/17/12 06:44      
      counting objects inserted in tube      Damir Tadic      03/17/12 11:31      
         What is the purpose of counting?      Andy Neil      03/17/12 11:42      
         Mirrors or multiple beams - still extremely cheap      Per Westermark      03/17/12 14:31      
         I guess there is a language problem here      Erik Malund      03/17/12 17:52      
            Specification Inadequate - Language Barrier?      Andy Neil      03/18/12 01:45      
               determine when receptacle at end of tube is full - Deja Vu?      Andy Neil      03/18/12 01:47      
            Language Barrier      Damir Tadic      03/18/12 13:54      
               "Simple and cheap" or dead reliable?        Kai Klaas      03/18/12 15:47      
               Not a solution?      Andy Neil      03/19/12 01:02      
               simple and cheap      Erik Malund      03/19/12 06:56      
   Do you know...      Kai Klaas      03/17/12 07:07      
   I hope      Erik Malund      03/17/12 08:45      
      eh?      Andy Neil      03/17/12 11:31      
         eh?      Erik Malund      03/17/12 17:42      
            Possible      Andy Neil      03/18/12 01:33      
               All This Pontificating....      Michael Karas      03/18/12 03:00      
                  Is a answer more important than the "correct" answer?      Per Westermark      03/18/12 04:17      
                     Sprung door with microswitch.      David Prentice      03/18/12 04:53      
                        Maybe but the bigger question was: what was tram destination      Per Westermark      03/18/12 06:17      
                        Already been suggested!      Andy Neil      03/18/12 08:10      
                  That information was not initially available      Andy Neil      03/18/12 08:07      

Back to Subject List